Record WT-0017 ยท Last verified September 2026
Crystal Quest Metal Removal (Iron, Manganese, Hydrogen Sulfide) Whole House Water Filter
Whole-house filter (well water) by Crystal Quest. No system-level certification found at NSF, IAPMO, WQA or CSA.

We may earn a commission. It never changes a grade.
Scorecard
| Measure | Grade | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Certification evidence | D | Maker claims only, no certification or published lab data |
| 10-year cost | A | $2,398 over 10 years |
| Flow rate | B | 9 gpm rated flow |
| Warranty | F | 1 years on main parts |
| Returns | D | 30 days, 30% restocking fee |
What it treats
"Certified" means an independent body (NSF, IAPMO, WQA or CSA) lists this system for that contaminant. "Lab tested" means the maker published a third-party lab report. "Maker claim" means neither.
| Contaminant | Evidence | |
|---|---|---|
| Iron | Maker claim | Other systems for Iron |
| Manganese | Maker claim | Other systems for Manganese |
| Hydrogen sulfide | Maker claim | Other systems for Hydrogen sulfide |
| Sediment | Maker claim | Other systems for Sediment |
| VOCs | Maker claim | Other systems for VOCs |
No claim made for: Chlorine, Chloramine, PFAS, Lead, Hardness, Bacteria, Arsenic, Nitrate, Fluoride, Copper, Uranium.
PFAS evidence: No PFAS claim for the standalone metal removal system (PFAS wording appears only for the optional SMART stage, uncertified).
Certifications
| Standard | Covers | Scope | Certified by |
|---|---|---|---|
| none (system) | No Crystal Quest system appears in NSF's drinking water treatment listings (search by manufacturer 'crystal' returns 'No Matching Products Found'). NSF public notice (page last updated 20 Apr 2022): prior to 9 Jun 2020 Crystal Quest sold water filter products bearing the NSF mark without having NSF-certified products or authorization to use the mark (nsf.org blocks plain HTTP with a 403; wording taken from the search-indexed page). Site badge 'ISO Certified' refers to an ISO 9001 quality-management certificate, not product performance. | system | none |
| NSF/ANSI 44 and NSF/ANSI 372 | Whole House Manual valve spec sheet: 'Tested and certified by the WQA to NSF/ANSI Standard 44 for water softener performance and NSF/ANSI Standard 372 for lead-free compliance.' Applies to the third-party control valve, not the filter system. | components | WQA (maker claim for the control valve only) |
Specifications
| Type | Whole-house filter (well water) |
|---|---|
| Technology | Sediment filtration, Specialty media, KDF media, Activated carbon |
| Water source | City water, Private well |
| Price | $1,331 to $5,697 |
| Rated flow | 9 gallons per minute |
| Capacity | 1,000,000 gallons (1.5 cu ft) or 1,500,000 gallons (2.0 cu ft) |
| Media | 20 in sediment cartridge, MetalX iron/manganese/H2S media (manganese dioxide coated zeolite, per MetalX data sheet), Eagle Redox Alloy 6500 and 9500, 20 in solid carbon block cartridge |
| Stages | 3 |
| Port size | 1 inch |
| Needs a drain | Yes |
| Needs power | Yes |
| DIY install | Professional install advised |
| Dimensions | tank 10 x 54 in (1.5 cu ft); overall footprint not stated |
| Weight | 270 lb |
| Warranty | One-year limited warranty on the system against defects in materials and workmanship (replacement filters excluded); RMA required. |
| Returns | 30-day returns from delivery, restocking fee up to 30% (the refund policy makes 30% mandatory on products $350 and over, which covers every configuration of this system), shipping not refunded, media not returnable. 'Guaranteed Performance' program: if an independent lab test (at the customer's expense) 1-3 months after install shows lack of performance, CQ attempts fixes (at customer's expense) and, failing that, refunds less shipping. CQ may refuse returns of products not installed by a qualified, licensed plumber. |
10-year cost
| Item | Each | Times in 10 years | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| System purchase | $1,331 | 1 | $1,331 |
| Installation (assumed, professional) | $500 | 1 | $500 |
| 20 in pleated sediment pre-filter cartridge, 2-7/8 x 20 in (CQE-RC-04015) | $32 | 9 | $284 |
| 20 in coconut carbon block post-filter cartridge, 2-7/8 x 20 in (CQE-RC-04014) | $32 | 9 | $284 |
| Total | $2,398 |
Install assumption: $500 for whole-house systems, $150 for under-sink units. Installing it yourself brings the total to $1,898. Try your own numbers in the 10-year cost calculator.
Owner reports
Brand-level, no model-specific pattern: Trustpilot (4.3 from 128) 1-2 star reviews repeatedly cite unanswered calls and emails, wrong or ill-fitting parts, housings leaking from badly seated O-rings, and systems underperforming their claims. One Trustpilot owner's lab test showed no iron or manganese reduction, and the single on-site Stamped review of this system (5 star) says instructions are online only and not detailed.
Trustpilot: 4.3 from 128 reviews (source).
CQ's whole-house collection page names iron removal as the lead system for private wells ('Iron Removal Whole House Filters for Well Water'); no dedicated 'well water' SKU exists. No maximum iron/manganese/H2S ppm stated on the page. Flow claim conflict: the MetalX data sheet (linked on the page) rates a 13x54 vessel with 2.0 cu ft at 4.40 GPM standard / 5.28 GPM max service flow, far below the 9-13 GPM CQ quotes for 10x54 and 12x52 tanks. No compare-at price shown.
Where we cover it
Alternatives in the same category
| System | Grade | Price | 10-yr cost | Certified to |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SpringWell WS1 | C | $2,231 | $2,731 | None |
| SpringWell WSSS1 | C | $3,124 | $3,624 | None |
| SoftPro Iron Master AIO | C | $1,517 | $2,692 | None |
| Aquasana Rhino Well Water with UV WH-WELL-UVS (WH-WELL-UV) | C | $1,749 | $8,523 | None |
| US Water Systems Flexx Oxi-Gen (081-FX) | C | $2,230 | $2,730 | None |
Sources
- crystalquest.com/products/iron-whole-house-water-filter
- cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1286/9985/files/metalX_PDS.pdf?v=1742224625
- cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1286/9985/files/MetalX_SDS.pdf?v=1742224626
- crystalquest.com/products/metal-removal-media
- crystalquest.com/collections/iron-manganese-and-hydrogen-sulfide-removal
- cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1286/9985/files/WholeHouseManual24v4.5.pdf?v=1726861859
- crystalquest.com/pages/warranty
- crystalquest.com/policies/refund-policy
- crystalquest.com/pages/our-guaranteed-performance
- crystalquest.com/collections/whole-house-water-filters
- crystalquest.com/collections/pfas-water-filters
- crystalquest.com/products/sediment-reusable-pleated-filter-cartridge
- crystalquest.com/products/coconut-based-carbon-block-filter-cartridge
- info.nsf.org/Certified/dwtu/listings.asp?CompanyName=crystal&Program=DWTU
- nsf.org/about-nsf/public-notices/crystal-quest
- trustpilot.com/review/crystalquest.com
- crystalquest.com/products/iron-whole-house-water-filter.json
- crystalquest.com/products/metal-removal-media.json
- stamped.io/api/widget/reviews?productId=752197763186&storeUrl=crystal-quest-water-filters.
- cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1286/9985/files/1.5_Iron_SMART_Anti_scale.pdf?2843
- crystalquest.com/products/sediment-reusable-pleated-filter-cartridge.json
- crystalquest.com/products/coconut-based-carbon-block-filter-cartridge.json
- trustpilot.com/review/crystalquest.com?stars=1&stars=2